Defocus Spectacle Lenses for Myopia Control
Guest article by Prof Dominique Bremond-Gignac
Professor of Ophthalmology,
Head of the Ophthalmology Department with pediatric subspecialty at University Hospital Necker-Enfants malades and Paris Cité University in Paris.
Affiliations:
1. Ophthalmology Department, Necker-Enfants Malades University Hospital, AP-HP, Paris Cité University, OPHTARA Rare Eye Diseases Reference Center, Paris, France
2. INSERM, UMRS1138, Team 17, From physiopathology of ocular diseases to clinical development, Sorbonne Paris Cité University, Centre de Recherche des Cordeliers, Paris, France.
Keywords:
Myopia control, Light, Defocus spectacle lenses, Syndromic myopia, refraction anomalies, ocular axial length
Financial disclosures:
Cooper, Essilor, HOYA, J&J, Krys, Santen, Thea, Zeiss.
Myopia is a refractive error of significant global public health concern and is primarily caused by an increase in the axial length of the eye. Myopia is considered a growing “global epidemic” due the rising prevalence of myopia worldwide. Myopia affects 85 to 90% of young adults in Asian countries such as Singapore and Taiwan, and said to affect approximately 25 to 50% of adults in the United States and Europe.1 Myopia can be classified as low (when less than -3D), moderate (between -3D and -5D) and high (worse than -5D). According to Holden et al, in 2000 approximately 1,406 million people had myopia (23% of the population) and nearly 163 million people with high myopia (< -5D), (2.7% of the population). By 2050, projections estimate 4,758 million people with myopia (49.8% of the population) and 938 million people with high myopia (< -5D), (9.8% of the population), amounting to nearly 5 billion people with myopia worldwide.6 Myopia carries a high risk of complications such as retinal detachment, myopic macular degeneration, early-onset cataracts, and glaucoma that are linked to the severity of myopia. Unfortunately, general population is not aware of myopia in children and its risks.3 In children with high myopia, it is important to investigate the possibility of syndromic myopia. Early detection of myopia onset and its progression is crucial for effective myopia control strategies.
Risk factors for myopia
A complex interaction between genetic predisposition and environmental exposure is thought to play a role in myopia. Parental myopia and twin studies indicate a role for genetic involvement. Especially in highly myopic cases, a genetic component is well-established, with families exhibiting high myopia where certain genes have been identified (such as 18p11.31, 12q21-31, and 7q36). Genome-wide association studies identified nearly 200 genes that appear to be associated with myopia, either individually or in combination. However, the growing prevalence is more likely due to the significant influence of environmental risk factors. Among the environmental factors, increased near-vision activities and limited outdoor time are considered to play a role. Extended near work including extended time on digital displays and limited outdoor time may influence light at the retina with impact on dopamine release and eye growth. Additionally, experimental models in animals and humans indicate that it is essential to also take into account factors such as visual deprivation, and peripheral hyperopic defocus.
Defocus corrective spectacle glasses are an easy and convenient way to treat children with myopia, as corrective lenses such as spectacles are needed anyway to correct myopia and restore vision.
Diagnosing myopia
In children, use of cycloplegia is recommended for an accurate diagnosis of myopia, because non-cycloplegic refractions may overestimate myopia. As high myopia in children can be an indicator of an associated syndrome (among other such as Stickler syndrome, Marfan syndrome, certain retinal dystrophies or congenital aniridia) a careful pediatric work-up must be performed in such cases.5
The challenge is to counteract the mid-retina sensory phenomenon of hyperopic defocus and to provide the best visual acuity through central accurate correction of the myopic refractive anomaly. Although correction of myopia with for example, spectacles or contact lenses restores vision, myopia can continue to progress and increase risk of developing sight-threatening complications, which therefore underscores the need for preventive measures to limit its progression and prevent visual impairment in adulthood.
In European populations, myopia is considered as fast progressing if it increases by -0.5D per year and/or 0.2mm per year in axial length. Evaluating axial length through optical biometry can be beneficial for the initial assessment and monitoring the progression of myopia. In cases of high or rapidly progressing myopia in children, a thorough pediatric and systemic evaluation is essential to identify any associated conditions and diagnose any potentially associated syndrome. In addition to clinical ocular and general phenotyping, targeted genetic studies for syndromic myopia will help refine the diagnosis. The ocular complications of myopia are partly a result of the elongation of the eyeball. These complications can potentially lead to blindness, such as retinal detachment, myopic choroiditis, subretinal neovascular complications, early cataracts, and glaucoma. They are more frequent and severe with higher degrees of myopia. These vision-threatening complications justify efforts to slow the progression of myopia.
Preventing the onset and reduce the progression of myopia
The challenge is to prevent the onset of myopia and on the other hand, to reduce or slow down its progression once it is already present. To prevent or delay onset of myopia, environmental measures such as increasing outdoor time reducing near work including screen time and early bedtime should be adopted. Nowadays, in eyes that are already myopic and progressing, we finally have efficient techniques at our disposal to control progression. 8, 9 Defocus corrective spectacle lenses and defocus contact lenses aim to reduce hyperopic defocus observed in myopic eyes at the mid peripheral to peripheral retina and therefore slow myopia. Orthokeratology remodels the cornea and the remodeled shape is considered to reduce peripheral hyperopic defocus. Low-dose atropine also slows myopia but the exact mechanism i.e., whether it acts via muscarinic receptors or on scleral collagen remains unknown. Since a myopic eye needs to be corrected to restore sight, of the various options, defocus corrective spectacle lenses which correct as well as slow myopia, appear to be a simple and convenient treatment option to apply in children. Although there are many different defocus spectacle lenses available with varying designs and concepts, however we need to focus only on systems that are supported by evidence from robust clinical studies.
Defocus spectacle lenses with robust clinical studies to manage myopia
Spectacle lens designs supported by evidence based on robust clinical studies include DIMS® (HOYA) defocus spectacle lenses including multiple segment with a defocus of 3.5D and HAL® (Essilor) defocus spectacle lenses including highly aspherical lenslets with a single vision central zone for both.2, 7 Recently, a new design for myopia control, incorporating cylindrical annular refractive elements, CARE® system (Zeiss), with a single vision central zone, has been developed. The complex lens technology has a mean power of myopic defocus in the 31 cylindrical annular refractive elements of +4.6D and a central zone of 7mm. CARE® Soft system is dedicated to older children due to ease of adaption. The mean power of myopic defocus is lower at +3.8D and central zone of 9mm. The 12-months interim results from a 2-year prospective multi-center trial has been presented at ARVO 2024. In children aged 6- to 13-year-olds, progression of myopia was significantly reduced with CARE® Spectacle lenses compared to single vision spectacles (-0.10 +/- 0.32D / 0.10 +/- 0.10 mm and -0.37+/- 0.39D / 0.20 +/- 0.16mm). With CARE® Soft Spectacle lenses, myopic progression was also significantly reduced compared to single vision spectacles (-0.13 +/- 0.27D / 0.11 +/- 0.11 mm and -0.38+/- 0.38D / 0.22 +/- 0.15mm). In children with progressive myopia, after 12 months of lens spectacle wear, compared to single vision spectacle lenses, ZEISS MyoCare and ZEISS MyoCare S demonstrated to slow down myopia significantly. 4 A longer follow up of this cohort will provide more relevant information.
Summary
In conclusion, the most promising treatments to manage and slow myopia include environmental measures, defocus corrective spectacle lenses, defocus contact lenses, orthokeratology, and low-dose atropine pharmacological treatments. Defocus corrective spectacle glasses are an easy and convenient way to treat children with myopia, as corrective lenses such as spectacles are needed anyway to correct myopia and restore vision. If the progression continues, there are options to combine defocus spectacle glasses and low-dose atropine to avoid an evolution to high myopia.
-
1
Baird, P. N., S. M. Saw, C. Lanca, J. A. Guggenheim, E. L. Smith Iii, X. Zhou, K. O. Matsui, P. C. Wu, P. Sankaridurg, A. Chia, M. Rosman, E. L. Lamoureux, R. Man, and M. He. 2020. 'Myopia', Nat Rev Dis Primers, 6: 99.
-
2
Bao, J., Y. Huang, X. Li, A. Yang, F. Zhou, J. Wu, C. Wang, Y. Li, E. W. Lim, D. P. Spiegel, B. Drobe, and H. Chen. 2022. 'Spectacle Lenses With Aspherical Lenslets for Myopia Control vs Single-Vision Spectacle Lenses: A Randomized Clinical Trial', JAMA Ophthalmol.
-
3
Robert MP, Daruich A, Bremond-Gignac D. Myopia: Insights from a population-based survey. Acta Ophthalmol. 2024;102(5):e869-e870. doi:10.1111/aos.16687
-
4
Chen, X., M. Li, J. Li, M. Wu, X. Liu, C. Yu, X. Guo, Y. Wang, Y. Wang, W. Lu, L. Li, and Y. Wang. 2024. 'One-year efficacy of myopia control by the defocus distributed multipoint lens: a multicentric randomised controlled trial', Br J Ophthalmol.
-
5
Flitcroft, I., J. Ainsworth, A. Chia, S. Cotter, E. Harb, Z. B. Jin, C. C. W. Klaver, A. T. Moore, K. K. Nischal, K. Ohno-Matsui, E. A. Paysse, M. X. Repka, I. Y. Smirnova, M. Snead, V. J. M. Verhoeven, and P. K. Verkicharla. 2023. 'IMI-Management and Investigation of High Myopia in Infants and Young Children', Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 64: 3.
-
6
Holden, B. A., T. R. Fricke, D. A. Wilson, M. Jong, K. S. Naidoo, P. Sankaridurg, T. Y. Wong, T. J. Naduvilath, and S. Resnikoff. 2016. 'Global Prevalence of Myopia and High Myopia and Temporal Trends from 2000 through 2050', Ophthalmology, 123: 1036-42.
-
7
Lam, C. S., W. C. Tang, P. H. Lee, H. Y. Zhang, H. Qi, K. Hasegawa, and C. H. To. 2022. 'Myopia control effect of defocus incorporated multiple segments (DIMS) spectacle lens in Chinese children: results of a 3-year follow-up study', Br J Ophthalmol, 106: 1110-14.
-
8
Sankaridurg, P., D. A. Berntsen, M. A. Bullimore, P. Cho, I. Flitcroft, T. J. Gawne, K. L. Gifford, M. Jong, P. Kang, L. A. Ostrin, J. Santodomingo-Rubido, C. Wildsoet, and J. S. Wolffsohn. 2023. 'IMI - 2023 Digest', Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, In Press.
-
9
Wildsoet, C. F., A. Chia, P. Cho, J. A. Guggenheim, J. R. Polling, S. Read, P. Sankaridurg, S. M. Saw, K. Trier, J. J. Walline, P. C. Wu, and J. S. Wolffsohn. 2019. 'IMI - Interventions Myopia Institute: Interventions for Controlling Myopia Onset and Progression Report', Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci, 60: M106-m31.